Alan's Favorite Bourbons

Alan's Other Bourbons Page

Always under review (Last update Feb 24, 2026)

High Tier (Premium) < $100 High Medium Low

Redbreast 10yr Irish Whiskey

10. Redbreast 10yr Irish Whiskey 80pf $57 ($64)

Smooth. Easy drink. Not too complex

Balcones Single Malt Single Barrel

10. Balcones Single Malt Single Barrel 110-120pf $70-$85

???

Eh Taylor Small Batch BIB

9.5 Eh Taylor Small Batch BIB $56

Very sweet. Cane sugar. No Spice

Eh Taylor Single Barrel BIB

9.5 Eh Taylor Single Barrel BIB $74

Very sweet & light. Very smooth.

Willet Small Batch Rye

9.4 Willet Small Batch Rye 107.4pf $74

Fruity (pear?). Little spice.

Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength

9. Penelope Toasted Barrel Strength 100pf $77

Flavorful. Slightly spicy but sweet

Widown Jane 10yr

8.5 Widown Jane 10yr 91pf $68

Very smooth

Omar Single Malt

8.0 Omar Single Malt (Taiwanese) 92pf $60

Smooth, not too spicey, easy to drink

WhistlePig Snout to Tail 10yr

8.0 WhistlePig Snout to Tail 88pf 10yr $78

???

Medium Tier (Mid-Shelf) $36-$55 High Medium Low

9.8 Heaven Hill 7yr BIB ($49)

Delicious. Sweet with many notes and quite smooth.

Four Roses

9.7 Four Roses (OBSV)

Smooth & Sweet

EagleRare

9.6. Eagle Rare

Very smooth but not as sweet or depth of flavors. Taste banana

Elijah Craig

9.4 Elijah Craig Small Batch 94pf $27 ($29)

Sweet & Smooth. Not spicey

Woodford Reserve Distillers Select

9.2 Woodford Reserve Distillers Select

Consistent sweet flavor, brown sugar, low spice

Michter's Small Batch

9.1 Michter's Small Batch

Delicious. Not too spicy. Leathery, sweet, sugary

Basil Hayden

9.0 Basil Hayden

Smooth. Light, not heavily sweet

Bulliet 10yr

9.0 Bulliet 10yr 91.2pf ($42)

???

Chicken Cock

9.0 Chicken Cock 80pf ($49)

???

Maker's Mark 46

9.0 Maker's Mark 46

Light spice. Misture of sweet/leather notes. Brown sugar

Whistle Pig Piggback SingleBarrel Alfa Rmoeo F1

9.0 Whistle Pig Piggback SingleBarrel Alfa Romeo F1 96.77pf ($50)

Strong cherry notes

Wild Turkey Rare Breed

8.9 Wild Turkey Rare Breed 115pf ($50)

A bit spicy but not too much. Lots of sweet notes

Russel's Reserve 10yr

8.4 Russel's Reserve 10yr 90pf ($34)

???

Bib & Tucker Double Char

8.3 Bib & Tucker Double Char 88pf $46.99

Sweet

Whistlepig Piggyback 6yr Rye

8.2 Whistlepig Piggyback 6yr Rye 96.56pf ($41)

Sweet brown sugar blends into a mildly sicy finish. The 100% rye is unexpectedly smooth with just a moderate earthy finish

Traveler's

7.9 Traveler's

Smooth & Sweeet. Not very complex

Low Tier (Well / Budget) < $35 High Medium Low

Old Grand-Dad 114

9.8. Old Grand-Dad 114

Delicious with a capital D. So sweet, you feel a little spice so you know you are drinking bourbon but not too much

1792 Small Batch

9.5 1792 Small Batch

Light with depth. Smooth. Cherry, Brown sugar notes

Nine Banded Straight

9.4 Nine Banded Straight

Smooth and light

Old Grand-Dad Bonded

9.3 Old Grand-Dad Bonded

Delicious. Complex, light sweet notes with low spicy finish

Buffalo Trace

9.0 Buffalo Trace 90pf ($25)

???

Evan Williams BIB

9.0 Evan Williams BIB

???

Sazerac Rye

8.9 Sazerac rye 90pf ($28)

Light sweetness. Threatens to get spicy but doesn't. Light leathery taste (in a good way). Bought 2nd bottle (1/28/2026) and still love it

Evan Williams Black

8 Evan Williams Black 86pf $20 ($13)

Sweet without a big burn

Knob Creek Rye

8.0 Knob Creek Rye 100pf $29 ($33)

Not too sweet. A little spicy

Old Forester

8.0 Old Forester 100pf $28 ($25)

???

1876

7.8 1876 (Dripping Springs Distillary) 3-5yr 84pf $33

Nutty barn flavor. Cobbler, pecan. not spicy. Very different profile

Tincup

7.7 Tincup 80pf ($26)

Lighter than others in this category. Smoother however with little to no spice.

Jim Beam Black

7.6 Jim Beam Black

TA bit spicy but has some nice sweet notes

Maker's Mark Straight

7.5 Maker's Mark Straight $24

???

Redemption

7.4 Redemption 88pf $25

Not bad for the price